This is my first foray into judging contests and I can honestly say I will never voluntarily judge another contest again. I’m just not cut out for it. I spent ALL DAY judging ONE 20 page entry. It’s just too hard.
Not that the story was terrible or the writing atrocious. No, not at all. It was technically sound with only minor errors. Overall, I think the score I gave is not bad, but it was torture for me.
I’m so ashamed and sorry to admit to feeling like that, I can’t even tell you.
It comes down to the lyricism of writing. If you’ve been reading my blog, you know what I mean. To me, writing has rhythm and movement. It should flow and carry you along with it. In the entry I judged today, despite it’s technical proficiency, it was like listening to the Best of the Worst of American Idol. The words were right, but the tone was just jarring. And I don’t think you can judge that, not with a point by point scoresheet that concentrates on the technical aspects of the entry.
So I’m done with judging. It’s simply too difficult and time consuming for me. I typed up a page of comments and made damned certain I was as encouraging as possible while offering what I admitted to being very subjective and personal feedback. That’s why people enter contests–for feedback, so I made sure I gave her a TON.
I still have more entries to go through. At this rate, one a day, I’ve got a few more days to go before I’m done.