BooksComing SoonNewsBiographyMedia KitContactS.J. Day
Change Font-Size: SmallChange Font-Size: Large
HomeSitemap
April 26th, 2005
Fed up

Alright. This topic has been beaten to death, but still I have to vent my anger and fear somewhere so my blog is as good a place as any. The last few weeks have really shocked me with the venom directed toward erotic romance. Loops, listservs, blog postings, the RITA fiasco. Now the RWR, where in a letter to the editor a writer says:

“Also we may want to stop prattling on about how ‘we just don’t get no respect’ when we allow dopey-looking hunks in ridiculous costumes advertising an erotic publisher
on our back cover. There’s a big difference between sensual romance and erotica, and I think we made a big mistake in lowering our standards to accept such a publisher.”

I get it. Some of you don’t like erotic romance. Fine. Whatever. Go ahead and complain. I don’t care. That is your right.

But here’s the deal. I don’t care. However, it appears my publishers may care and this frightens me.

First, you have Black Lace. My most recent letter from them says:

Editorial Changes: Please be aware that we want to tone down the four-letter words a bit for future compilations. We preferably want only one sex scene per story, beautifully described and perhaps more subtle than previous Black Lace writing. We are trying to get the books off the top shelf here in the UK, and out to a wider audience. For that, we need to reduce the use of ‘f’ and ‘c’ words.

There’s more, but you get the drift.

Then one of my other publishers recently turned down a collection from a friend of mine because the stories were “too erotic” for their “erotica” line.

Yesterday, a writer for still another of my publishers warned us on the loop that every ‘f’ word in her ms was cut, even when it was used as a curse and not a reference to the sexual act. When she complained she was told vitriolic reviewers had managed to change editorial policy for the publisher.

And Ghede never made it off the ground “due to the current conservative climate”.

What does this mean? Censorship. Plain and ‘f’ing simple. Publishers need to make money. Conseratives keep stirring the pot and publishers get scared. When my publishers get scared, so do I.

Is this because I can’t write any other way? Do I have to use four-letter words in my stories? Of course not. That’s not my point. My point is the option should exist for people to exercise their constitutionally guaranteed right to freedom of speech and let’s face it people, it’s slowly eroding away in the case of erotic romance. Rumor has it EC is prepared to move their operation outside the US if this type of bullsh!t keeps up. It’s very, very ridiculous that people who don’t like something feel that they are superior enough to demean and suppress others rather than taking their @ss and the stick that’s shoved up it elsewhere. :evil: If you don’t like erotic romance, don’t read it. It’s just that simple. Just because you don’t like it doesn’t mean it should go away.

The publishers are feeling forced to change their guidelines due to pressure and it just isn’t right. This isn’t a case of them making changes because they want to. There should be something for everyone. There are inspirational publishers and imprints, and there are erotic publishers and imprints. Why are the erotic romance publishers facing all of this pressure? I just don’t understand it at all.

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

If you enjoyed this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed!

No related posts.

(1,374 views)

27 Responses to “Fed up”

  1. Lydia says:

    “Erotica” is a hot TERM right now, but to be honest, publishers are discovering that most people just don’t really want erotica–or even romantica. Most readers want “erotica” just to mean “hottish romance, maybe with an unconventional element or two.” My two finished books are considerably hotter than quite a few authors who call themselves “erotic,” and I would describe them at most as “sensual.” I’m not being a snob–I know what erotica is, and what I write ain’t it.

    Basically, it comes down to marketing-ese and what people REALLY want. What they want is different than what labels they’re looking for in their books. Romance is what their mothers read–THEY like “erotica.” :roll:

    This isn’t about censorship. It’s about sales–what the book business has always been about. A certain type of book has co-opted a “racy” word just because of the buzz, but that doesn’t mean that the content will follow when there’s no demand for it.

    One big problem with the current use of the word “erotica” is that you REALLY have no idea if you’ve getting borderline R or XXX stuff just from the name!

  2. [...] ow, there’s been conversation across the blogosphere the last few days about readers speaking out to publishers and making known their thoughts on certain elements in f [...]

  3. Teresa says:

    Such a tizzy. Where do people get off dictating to others what they should or shouldn’t read/like/enjoy etc? I don’t get it. Personally, erotica isn’t my thing. And EC’s covers don’t always thrill me (some even make me giggle). Does that mean I want erotica writers to stop using the “f” and “c” words? Does that mean I demand EC or any of the other erotica publishers change their covers? Hell no!!! I don’t give a damn. If anyone thinks the romance genre will gain more respectability by doing so, they’re wrong. Let’s face it – there will always be detractors. And censoring ourselves is not the answer.:roll:

  4. Caro says:

    I remember about seven or eight years ago a letter in the RWR where someone begged her fellow writers to stop writing steamy love scenes because “they hurt Our Lord.” The letters you quoted have the same tone — stop what you’re doing because I don’t approve of it. What’s more, these people are not going to shut up because there will always be things they disapprove of.

    “Lowering our standards?” That’s a load of crap — the covers for Ellora’s Cave are no worse than some of the covers with Fabio dry humping the middle of the heroine’s back and while we decry them, no one talks about romance writers lowering their standards because of it.

    But it is true that we need to write to the publishers, let them know that the lines have fans and people who love them –it’s difficult for a small operation like EC, who doesn’t have the resources of an Avon or Warner, but the big publishers need to know that its not just the people who are looking to be offended who are out there and willing to put pen to paper.

  5. Wendy says:

    Wh..wh..what?! Please tell me you made up that Black Lace submission blurb :mad: I like my Black Lace the way it is dagnabit. I like the rougher language! I like the heroines who actually enjoy sex! Heck, I like the gay characters who are drawn as “real people” and not two-dimensional child-molesting villains!

    Ugh. I’m so ticked I could spit nails :evil:

  6. Sylvia says:

    Yes, I agree with that, Alison. I made that point to my sister who had some Air Force trouble. I told her to write to our Senator. She said, “What for? I’m nobody.” But she wrote anyway and has received several letters written by the Senator who is looking into the matter.

    A letter is a powerful thing.

  7. Alison says:

    No. It’s not completely pointless – except a letter in hand written DIRECTLY to a publisher or editor and addressed to them BY NAME has a whopping lot more impact that conversational posts online. Those letters are passed around in house. Discussions online are not consumer complaints or consumer praise RECEIVED IN HOUSE that get logged. Businesses have specific departments that handle such things. They’re required to handle them by policy. (I can give you a concrete example where this happened with ONE letter writer and Blaze – where the letter got a response STRAIGHT FROM THE TOP! *g* Got it? ONE LETTER! *g*) That’s where the strength lies. Those letters where the consumer/reader has taken the time and the effort to take his/her feelings to the top.



  • Search

  • Sylvia Day

    "Sylvia Day is the undisputed mistress of tender, erotic romance. Her books are a luxury every woman deserves."
    -- Teresa Medeiros,
    New York Times bestselling author
  • Twitter

  • On this day...

  • New Release!

    Eve of Chaos
    Try! | Buy!

    Still Available

    In The Flesh
    Try! | Buy!

    Eve of Destruction
    Try! | Buy!

    Coming Next

    The Stranger I Married
    Try! | Buy!
  • Sylvia’s Sinners

    Sylvia's Sinners

    Wicked Chat Loop

    Wicked Writers - Chat Loop for Readers

    Murder She Writes

    Murder She Writes

    Brava Authors

    RAW 2009

    Lora Leigh's RAW 2009

    Romancing the Blog

    www.JanusPortal.com
  • RSS Sylvia’s Latest RTB Posts

  • Free Reads

    Catching Caroline

    Snaring The Huntress


    Show Some Love


    My e-Books

    Magic and Mayhem
    Magical/Halloween

    Wish List
    Contemporary/Holiday
    * EPPIE Winner

    Kiss of the Night
    Futuristic Vampire
    Dangerous II

    Misled
    Futuristic Vampire
    Dangerous I

  • What the Critics Say

    …[one] of the more noted authors of erotic romance… — Library Journal

  • Blog RSS Syndication

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner


    AddThis Feed Button
  • Newsletter

      Email
      Confirm email
      Preferred format for emails:
      Text HTML

    2009 Releases

  • RSS Latest News

  • RSS Recently on the Message Board

  • Pages

  • Book Trailers

  • Get the Gear!



    Support Indie Bookstores

    indiebound

  • My Books

    Alluring Tales: Hot Holiday Nights
    Magical/Shapeshifter

    Ask For It
    Historical (Georgian)
    Georgian Series I

    Don't Tempt Me
    Historical (Georgian)
    Georgian Series IV
    *Romantic Times Reviewers' Choice Award Winner
    * 2009 Winter Rose Award Winner

    Heat of the Night
    Fantasy/Contemporary
    Dream Guardians® II

    A Passion for Him
    Historical (Georgian)
    Georgian Series III

    Passion for the Game
    Historical (Georgian)
    Georgian Series II
    * Romantic Times Reviewers' Choice Award Nominee
    * Laurel Wreath Award Winner

    Pleasures of the Night
    Fantasy/Contemporary
    Dream Guardians® I
    * PRISM Finalist

    The Stranger I Married
    Historical (Regency)

    Declassified: Dark Kisses
    Futuristic Vampire
    Print Combo "Misled" & "Kiss of the Night"

    Ask For It
    Historical (Georgian)
    Georgian Series I

    Bad Boys Ahoy!
    Historical (Regency)
    Bad Boys I
    * RITA© Finalist
    * Aspen Gold Readers' Choice Winner

    Quickies #7
    Contemporary

    Perfect Kisses
    Historical (Regency)
    Bad Boys II
    * RITA© Finalist

    Perfectly Plum
    Non-Fiction/Pop Culture

    The Write Ingredients
    Non-Fiction/Cookbook

    Alluring Tales
    Magical/Shapeshifter

    White Hot Holidays
    Contemporary/Holiday
    * EPPIE Winner

    Dreams of the Oasis II
    Futuristic

    Click to read more
    Contemporary

  • Archives

  • Hosted by

    Exceptional, affordable website hosting for the discerning business owner